Why a Direct Debit comes back unpaid
When the tenant's bank does not pay a Direct Debit, it returns it with a reason code. The code tells you what can happen next.
- Refer to payerThe tenant's bank could not pay, usually because there was not enough money in the account. The payment can usually be re-presented, which means collected again.
- Instruction cancelledThe tenant or their bank has cancelled the Direct Debit Instruction, the mandate that lets you collect. There is nothing left to collect against until the tenant sets up a new one.
- Account closed or transferredThe account no longer exists or has moved to another bank. You need new details from the tenant.
Indemnity claims under the Direct Debit Guarantee
A rent payment can also be reversed after it was collected. Under the Direct Debit Guarantee, a tenant who reports an error gets a full and immediate refund from their own bank.
The tenant's bank then raises an indemnity claim, and the refund is taken back from your account or your provider's. You can challenge a claim through your bank or Direct Debit provider, on limited grounds. You need evidence that the payment matched the advance notice the tenant received.
A successful claim does not erase the debt. If the amount and date were correct, the rent is still owed. After a claim, reopen the rent period, decide whether to challenge, and ask the tenant how they will pay.
Standing orders and returned transfers
A standing order is an instruction the tenant gives their own bank. The tenant can change or cancel it at any time, and you are not told. There is no guarantee scheme like the one for Direct Debits.
So a stopped standing order often shows up only as a missing payment on the bank statement. A one-off transfer can also come back, for example when the account details are wrong. In both cases, the rent stays open.
Read more: Direct Debit, standing order or open banking
Reesure confirms each rent payment at the point of transaction, so your team sees which payments failed and can decide on the follow-up.
What to do after a failed payment
- Reopen the rent periodReopen the charge for the rent period it belongs to, and record the return in the cash book on the date it arrives.
- Check the reason codeRe-present the Direct Debit only where the scheme allows it, such as refer to payer, and only if the instruction is still active. Tell the tenant the new collection date before you re-present.
- Contact the tenantAsk what happened and agree how and when the rent will be paid.
- Follow your usual arrears processIf the rent still does not arrive, treat it like any other missed payment.
Read more: Rent reconciliation and month-end close · Rent arrears letters: stages and timing
No fee for a returned payment in England
The Tenant Fees Act 2019 covers private tenancies in England, such as assured shorthold and other private assured tenancies. Social housing tenancies are outside these fee rules.
Under the Act, only two defaults can carry a fee: late rent, and replacing a lost key or other security device. A separate charge for a returned payment is not on that list.
A late rent fee needs a clause in the tenancy agreement, and the rent must be unpaid for 14 days. It is capped at interest of 3% a year above Bank Rate (often called the base rate).
Read more: Rent arrears: how late rent interest is calculated
Checked on 20 November 2026 against multiple sources.
This is a general explanation, not advice for your situation.